A New Pedagogy for the Lac-Operon
INTRODUCTION
It has long troubled this author that students have found learning the lac-operon a confusing activity even though having once learned it and looking back it is found to be rather simple. A new way of presenting it seems to be in order. Good pedagogy instructs going from the known into the unknown, AND not drowning the student in all the facts at the start. Evolve the learning experience!
What is 'known' to students is that there are genes that are either working or not working. They have, for example, already studied Mendel's peas. The pea plant will either have the gene or it won't. So let's make that our starting point in teaching the students about operons.
Thus, you as the teacher can initially diagram the gene as a portion of a line you have drawn on the board. You can call it "lac", to introduce the students to the three-letter nomenclature of genetics. Then as each of the following steps continue, you must refine your diagram and its terminology.
The various bacterial strains used in here are listed near the end of this document along with the specifics for making the needed agars for the petri plates.
STEP ONE: The Gene LacZ and Its Enzyme ß-gal'ase
To start, the students will comprehend that E.coli can have a gene that codes for an enzyme that can clip the sugar lactose in half. This is easily demonstrated by having the students look at a collection of petri plates containing MacConkey agar with and without selected sugars. Those without any sugar or are lacking the gene give negative test results. They can also look inside of those bacteria growing on lactose plates and find the enzyme ß-galactosidase ("ß-gal'ase") by using the ONPG test. There will be no surprises here for the students. All is as expected.
Refinements: you can talk about starting and stopping of transcription. There must be a "start" and a "stop" for your gene so the transcriptase will know what it is doing. So you add two short sequences to the beginning and end of the "lac" section. Rename the "start" to "promoter", that "stop" is a good word in most languages. (This gives you also an opportunity to talk about the world community of scientists and the need to be able to communicate - so words that are universal are best chosen to name things.)
Lab set-up: Three MacConkey plates are made: (Be sure that you buy MacConkey powder that contains NO sugars.) To one batch add no sugars; make another batch to about 0.5% lactose, and another batch to 0.3% glucose. Also make make three plates using nutrient agar: no sugar ("NS"), lactose, and glucose. (In both cases the NS and glucose plates are not shown to the students until they've gotten to Step Two, below.) Show the students the MacConkey agar reactions: E.coli are among the few bacteria that ferment sugars to acids. MacConkey agar contains crystal violet that poison electron transport so that the bacteria are forced to grow anaerobically (ferment), and the methyl red is a pH indicator that forms a red precipitate below about pH 4.5. So when E.coli ferments a sugar to an acid, a red colony grows up. Thus a lactose fermenting colony is red if lactose has been incorporated in the MacConkey agar.
Next introduce a bit of chemistry: the ONPG test. This is a neat way to trick an enzyme by using an analog. So discuss analogs, which are very important throughout biochemistry and in chemotherapy. This will be a real eye-opener for the students as it will show them a means by which they can tell if something is inside of a cell or not.
STEP TWO: Inducibility
Here is where inductibility is introduced. Some of the colonies on the above plates containing no sugars or glucose can be subjected to the ONPG test, and the students will discover that there is no ß-gal'ase in the cells. Yet those are the same strains that were grown on the lactose and did possess the enzyme! This is a very big item for discussion: the turning on and off of genes. You can talk about development and maturation of the students themselves. Then mention how hard it would be run tests to discover the mechanisms by which certain stages of development are initiated, and that by looking to extremely simple systems such as found in the bacterium, we can discover what is going on. So we need to refine the line diagram on the board to having some sort of switch. Let us call it an "operator" which must be somewhere very close to the promoter so that it will either allow transcriptase to start, or will prevent it from doing so. Of course, up to this moment, the students have no idea about how this operator might work. This allows you to introduce the idea that the "switch" is really more complicated than it looks. So you bring in the notion of a repressor protein that was encoded by the gene LacR. You can now bring in the sophisticated notion of "DNA-binding sites" - there are sections in proteins that bind to DNA, and this binding must be highly specific. Transcriptase binds to promoter regions in the DNA, while repressors bind to operator regions in DNA. Obviously there must be many similar promoter regions scattered around as each gene must have one at its beginning, but operator regions are generally unique.
Lab Set-Up: Suppose we have an inducible gene for an enzyme that
degrades lactose. We put the wild-type and a Z- on
lactose+MacConkey, lactose+NB, and "ns"+NB The two
grow on all the plates, and on the red plate, the Wild
one make a red colony, and the Z- does not. If we
look inside of the cells using the ONPG test, then we
see that the Wild has ß-gal'ase on the Lactose+NB, but
not when grown on the "NS" plate. The Z- strain does
not test positive for ß-gal'ase in either case. The
enzyme cannot be induced in any case! Must be that a
functional cistron is missing. Everything seems
simple. Thus the switch, lacR and lacO are also called
into existence.
STEP THREE: Active Transport (LacY)
Just to check this out, let's take a look at a small
collection of strains that do not make red colonies on
the lactose red plate. So a lactose red plate is passed out with four
non-red colonies (and a center red colony as control).
The non-red colonies are lifted from a lactose plate
and subjected to the ONPG test. Three show no yellow
from the ONPG, but one does give yellow color. So
this bug is inducible (no yellow from cells lifted
from the NS plate). But for some reason didn't give
red colony on red plate. Ask if any kids have any
ideas what might be happening. Zero in on active
transport: and that this mutant must not have the
active transport mechanism. So there must be a second
cistron in that operon - let's call it LacY, and its mutant would be termed LacY-.
STEP FOUR: Regulators (LacO or LacR)
If the students take a look at several bugs that gave
red colonies on the red plates, they find that there
is one that gives a positive ONPG test no matter what
sugars were or were not around. Discuss what this
might be. A damaged O, or a damaged DNA-binding site
on the R. Thus the students are seeing that even the regulator genes can be damaged (mutated). In this specific case, when the operator has a nonsensical sequence to which the lacR repressor protein cannot bind, we would call it a constitutive mutant (Lac Oconstit.
Conclusion
These four steps allow the students to go from
simplicity to complexity - each time being able to
build confidently upon the previous well-understood 'simple' form.
STRAINS
About the bacterial strains that are being used. A great number of different ones are available. Below are given several that have historical significance.
They are all derivatives of E.coli K-12 (remember the
girl in the early 1920's who sat in row K seat 12 in
the class that was taken over by a grad student named
Joshua Lederberg. He was teaching because his boss, Fred Avery, was in
the hospital for an extended time. The girl happened
to be lucky and had isolated from the wild two
different strains of E.coli that could exchange genes.
One of those was the donor, and was eventually
denominated "K-12". It was actually an F+ (possessing the
F-plasmid). Many mutants have since been made from that strain,
and some have even had their F-plasmids "cured" (gotten rid
of). The strains that you may be using with your
students are these. And I have appended their
official numbers from the Cold Spring Harbor Lab
(Watson is now director) on "LonGisland." Full
genotypes are given:
CSH-25: Wild: Lac+ F- supF thiamine- (requires
trace of vitamin B1 to grow. Get some at health food
store if I failed to give you any in the past. Less
than a cubic millimeter is needed per liter. TRACE!
CSH-39: lacZ-: F'-lacZ-pro+/lac,pro(deletion)thiamine-
Here you have a bug that has a defective lac-operon
and a good proline operon inserted in the F-plasmid.
The somatic chromosome is normal except that both the
lac and pro operons are completely deleted. If ever
you want to show sexduction (conjugation), cross this
strain with one that is pro- and you will quickly get
a culture in which there are no pro-. This strain can
also be used to show segregation of alleles: grow it
on medium with glucose and proline. The pro+ operon
is not needed and if the plasmid gets lost, no matter
to the cell. But by later testing it on medium
without proline, those segregants will no longer grow.
The mutation on the Z-cistron is due to an "amber"
mutation - the wrong codon assignment for one of the
amino acids. However, if this plasmid is inserted
into cells that have a mutated tRNA for that same
amino acid, the cistron can be read!
CSH-40: lacY-: Almost exactly like CSH-39 except
merely substitute lacY- for 39's lacZ-.
CSH-37: lacOconstit: Again like CSH-39 except merely
substitute a damaged lacO. (This is a partially
constitutive mutant - and might not give stunning
yellows in the ONPG test when inducer is NOT present.
But we saw, on the picnic bench that some yellow did
occur.)
I think you might be getting the idea that while these
strains are useful tools for teaching the rudiments of
the lac-operon, they are also very powerful genetic
tools for subsequent experiments - on the graduate
school level.
PETRI PLATE PREPARATION
Plan so that each plastic petri plate needed should contain about 25 ml of agar, and each glass plate 30 ml. In the following are given recipes for 100 ml (4 plastic plates or 3 glass plates).
MacConkey Agar Plates: 5 gm of MacConkey Agar without lactose (or any other sugar for that matter!). If addition of a sugar is desired, add 0.3 to 0.5 gm of that sugar. Then add about 100 ml of TAP water (these are living things and need minerals just like you do!). Swirl to get everything in suspension, cover, sterilize. Swirl (shaking is a no-no! - might be super-heated; besides you will get a lot of foam) again as soon as taken out of the sterilizer to suspend the agar syrup at the bottom of the container.
Luria Agar: 0.7 gm of tryptone + a trace of vitamin B1 (thiamine). (By a 'trace' is meant a speck about the size of a granule of table sugar.) If addition of a sugar is desired, add 0.3 to 0.5 gm of that sugar. And don't forget to add 2 gm of pure agar powder! Then add about 100 ml of TAP water. Swirl to get everything in suspension, cover, sterilize. Swirl (shaking is a no-no! as the liquid might be super-heated and become an uncontrollable gyser of boiling liquid; besides you will get a lot of foam) again as soon as taken out of the sterilizer to suspend the agar syrup at the bottom of the container.
ONPG Test: Dissolve about 200 mg of o-nitro-phenyl-ß-D-galactopyranoside (ONPG) in 25 ml of water. This will take nearly 30 minutes with a magnetic stirrer. It is now ready to use in droppers.
I want to go to the TOP OF PAGE or ESCAPE! or go back to the Intro Lab's Home Page! or W&M course info
INGREDIENTS
Sugars Glucose and Lactose
Agars Plain agar, and
MacConkey Agar without lactose
Other Tryptone powder,
NaCl, thiamine
(vitamin B1)